Pitcher and Gravity Filters

Gravity Water Filters: ProPur and DIY Berkey Builds

Gravity water filters explained: ProOne and Propur systems, Berkey-style elements, and the safety limits of DIY bucket builds you should know.

On this page
  1. The short answer
  2. How gravity filters work
  3. ProOne and Propur systems
  4. Berkey-style filters
  5. Side by side
  6. The DIY bucket build: what it gets right and wrong
  7. Downsides of gravity filtration
  8. Is a gravity filter better than a Brita?
  9. Who gravity filters suit

The short answer

A gravity filter has an upper chamber for untreated water, filter elements in the middle, and a lower chamber for filtered water. Water moves through the elements by gravity, so the system needs no power or plumbing. You can buy a commercial system, such as ProOne (sold under the Propur name in some listings) or a Berkey-style unit, or you can build one from buckets. Commercial systems use manufactured elements with published test data. A bucket build depends entirely on the cartridges you choose and how well you run it, so it carries more risk.

How gravity filters work

Water is poured into the top chamber, passes through one or more filter elements, and collects in the bottom chamber, where a spigot dispenses it. The flow rate depends on the element design, how full the top chamber is, and whether the elements are primed. Gravity systems are simple, which is part of their appeal, and they keep working during a power outage.

ProOne and Propur systems

ProOne and Propur appear to be closely related. A reviewer who used both says ProOne was formerly named Propur, and many sellers still list the systems under the Propur name. For a closer look at the naming question, see whether ProOne and Propur are the same.

Key points from the sources we reviewed:

  • Filter generations: The ProOne G3.0 is the current filter. The G2.0 is the older filter, and at least one reviewer used it in a Berkey.
  • Priming: ProOne says its filters don’t need priming. Discard the first couple of cycles, because they can carry sediment from the filter.
  • Capacity: ProOne lists gravity systems in several sizes. The Big+ is about three gallons, and the Traveler+ is about 2.25 gallons. A reviewer described the Propur Big at 2.75 gallons.
  • Filter life: Sources disagree. One reviewer rated the G2.0 at six months per filter. Another review reported that Propur recommends replacing filters about once a year. Check the manual for your exact model.
  • Certifications: ProOne says its filter is NSF/ANSI 42 component certified and that its stainless gravity systems are NSF certified. Its lab reports list many contaminants. Those are the manufacturer’s claims, so check the report for the exact model you buy.

Berkey-style filters

Berkey systems use Black Berkey elements, which the company rates at 3,000 gallons per element, or 6,000 gallons per pair. Berkey says its standard elements don’t reduce fluoride, and that fluoride reduction needs separate PF-2 filters. Berkey’s own FAQ also says its elements don’t remove the minerals that make water hard, so your TDS reading won’t change much.

Black Berkey elements need priming before first use. Priming is covered in how to prime a Berkey gravity filter, and element life is covered in how long Berkey gravity filters last.

Side by side

ProOne / Propur Berkey-style
Priming Company says none needed Required for Black Berkey elements
Fluoride Company says its filter reduces fluoride Needs separate PF-2 filters
Filter life Sources differ (six or twelve months) Rated 3,000 gallons per element
Chambers Stainless steel Stainless steel
Price Varies by size and seller Varies by size and seller

The table reflects company claims and reviewer reports. Read the current manual and data sheet for the model you buy.

The DIY bucket build: what it gets right and wrong

A common DIY design uses two food-grade buckets. You drill holes in the bottom of the upper bucket for filter cartridges, drill a few holes in the lid so water can flow between the buckets, and let gravity move water through the cartridges into the lower bucket. The forum post we reviewed reported good results, with clear water and no bleach taste.

The build has several risks that the post does not address:

  • Cartridge certification. The post doesn’t say which contaminants its cartridges were tested for. Check the NSF listing for the exact cartridge you buy. A cartridge that is certified for one contaminant is not certified for others.
  • Bleach is not a general treatment. The post treats untreated water with household bleach to kill parasites. Chlorine does not reliably kill every waterborne parasite, and Cryptosporidium is resistant to it. Viruses and parasites need different treatment, which is why boiling is the reliable first step for water of unknown safety.
  • Stored water can grow microbes. Berkey’s own FAQ recommends replacing or topping up stored water after about three days, and sooner in warm rooms. Keep your buckets covered and clean.
  • Filters don’t fix everything. A bucket system doesn’t reduce a contaminant unless its cartridge does.
  • No independent test. The “3,000 gallons” figure in the post is an unverified claim. Your cartridges’ actual life depends on your water.

If you build one anyway, use food-grade containers, buy cartridges certified for the contaminants you need, clean the buckets and cartridges on a schedule, keep the containers covered, and boil water from an unknown or unsafe source before you filter it. For the basics, see the simplest way to purify water at home.

Downsides of gravity filtration

  • Counter space. Gravity systems are tall and take up room.
  • Slow fill. You may need to refill the top chamber several times a day to keep up with demand.
  • Upkeep. Cleaning, priming and element replacement all take time.
  • Upfront cost. A stainless system costs more to start than a pitcher, although per-gallon costs can be lower.
  • Not a disinfection plan. A gravity filter does not make microbiologically unsafe water safe. Boil or disinfect first when the source is unknown.

Is a gravity filter better than a Brita?

They are different tools. A gravity system holds more water and is better suited to a household that drinks a lot of filtered water or needs water away from a power source. A pitcher is cheaper to start and takes less room, but it holds less water and needs more frequent refills. Neither is better across the board. Check the certifications for the specific model and match them to what is in your water. The ZeroWater vs PUR vs Brita comparison covers the pitcher side.

Who gravity filters suit

  • Households that need a lot of filtered water every day
  • People without reliable plumbing access, or who want an off-grid option
  • Travelers and people who want a portable system for emergencies
  • Anyone who wants a filter that works during a power outage

For any of these, check the certifications, the filter life for your water, and a boil plan for water of unknown quality.

The complete guide to pitcher and gravity filters

ZeroWater vs PUR vs Brita: Which Pitcher Filter Is Best?
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →