The short answer
No single pitcher is best for every kitchen. The right choice depends on two things: how many dissolved solids your tap water already carries, and which contaminants you want reduced.
- ZeroWater removes nearly all dissolved solids, so its meter can read close to zero. Its filter life depends heavily on your tap water, and in high-solids water the filters can be used up quickly.
- Brita Elite is the most predictable of the three for most homes. It has a long rated life and is the Brita filter made for lead reduction.
- PUR is a long-running pitcher brand. Its certifications differ by model, so compare the specific filter in the box rather than the brand name.
If you do nothing else, test your tap water before you buy. A cheap TDS meter and your home’s lead results will tell you more than any brand comparison.
How each brand filters
Brita pitcher filters use activated carbon and ion-exchange media. Brita’s Elite filter is a different design from its Original filter. According to Brita, water flows through the sides of the Elite filter instead of the bottom.
ZeroWater uses a five-stage ion-exchange system. It removes nearly all dissolved solids, including minerals such as calcium and magnesium. Each pitcher includes a TDS meter so you can check the output yourself.
PUR pitcher filters are carbon-based, and their certifications vary by model. Two PUR filters can look alike and certify different contaminants, so read the package.
What each one is certified to reduce
Certifications are the most useful guide, and they belong to specific filters rather than whole brands. Look for:
- NSF/ANSI 42 for taste, odor and chlorine
- NSF/ANSI 53 for health-related contaminants such as lead
- NSF/ANSI 401 or P473 where they matter to you, such as certain pharmaceuticals or PFOA and PFOS
Brita says its Elite is the filter it markets for lead reduction, and that its Original is aimed mainly at chlorine taste and odor. ZeroWater reports NSF/ANSI 42 and 53 certification for lead and several other contaminants. Check the current performance data sheet for each model before you rely on any of these claims, because certifications change by model and over time.
A filter that removes more is not automatically the better choice for you. Tap water is usually a minor source of calcium and magnesium, but many people notice the taste change when those minerals are removed.
Taste and minerals
- ZeroWater water is very low in dissolved solids. Some people find it tastes flat, and exhausted filters can taste sour, fishy or metallic.
- Brita and PUR keep most minerals in the water. They are mainly chosen for better taste and chlorine reduction, along with the specific contaminants on their certification lists.
Filter life and cost per gallon
Running cost is the part most buyers miss. Use this formula with your own numbers:
cost per gallon = price of one filter ÷ gallons it actually filters
For example, a filter that costs 10 dollars and lasts 40 gallons works out to 25 cents a gallon. The same filter used up after 15 gallons costs about 67 cents a gallon. The gap between those two results is why water quality matters so much.
- Brita Original is rated for about 40 gallons, roughly two months.
- Brita Elite is rated for 120 gallons, roughly six months.
- PUR pitcher filters are commonly rated around 40 gallons or two months, depending on the model.
- ZeroWater life varies with your tap water. ZeroWater’s guidance is to replace the pitcher filter when the meter reads 006 or higher.
Let your water decide
- Test your tap TDS. A ZeroWater filter lasts longer on low-solids water and runs out much faster on water with a few hundred parts per million or more.
- Check your utility’s water quality report. It will show many regulated contaminants, but lead often comes from home plumbing and fixtures. A utility report may not show it, so a lead test at the tap is more useful for that question.
- Well water needs a different first step. A pitcher filter is not a disinfectant. If you draw water from a well, test for bacteria before you rely on any pitcher. See the simplest way to purify water at home for the basics.
How to choose
- Choose Brita Elite if you want a predictable filter cost, a long rated life and lead reduction.
- Choose ZeroWater if you want the lowest dissolved-solids output possible, your tap water is low in solids, and you are comfortable with the taste and the filter schedule.
- Choose PUR if you already use a model that matches your certification needs. Don’t switch brands without checking that the new filter certifies what you care about.
For how the Brita line compares in detail, see the Brita filter review. For ZeroWater’s filter schedule, see how long ZeroWater filters last.
FAQ
Do Brita and PUR use the same filter?
No. Each brand designs its own cartridges, and they are not interchangeable. Brita says its Elite filter may physically fit some non-Brita pitchers, but it is only certified for contaminant reduction in Brita pitchers and dispensers. Check the certification for the pitcher you own before you buy a cartridge for it.
Are charcoal water filters better?
Carbon filters are good at reducing chlorine taste and odor, and many also reduce some other contaminants. They do not remove dissolved solids the way ion exchange does. Whether a carbon filter is “better” depends on what you are trying to reduce, so check the certification list for the specific filter.