Pitcher and Gravity Filters

Is it better to drink bottled water or Brita filtered water?

Brita-filtered tap water usually costs less per gallon and makes less plastic waste than bottled water, but neither is automatically safer. Here's how to decide.

On this page
  1. The short answer
  2. Start with your tap water
  3. Who regulates what
  4. Cost per gallon
  5. Plastic and the environment
  6. Microplastics and other contaminants
  7. When bottled water makes sense
  8. When a filter makes sense
  9. A quick decision path

The short answer

For most homes with tap water that meets local standards, filtered tap water costs less per gallon and creates far less plastic waste than bottled water. Neither option is automatically safer. Bottled water makes more sense when your tap water is unsafe or unknown, or when you’re traveling or in an emergency. Start with your tap water report, then compare the two on cost and what each one actually removes.

Start with your tap water

A pitcher or faucet filter only improves what it is certified to reduce. Before you choose, find out what is in your water:

  • Utility report. In the United States, your water utility publishes an annual Consumer Confidence Report listing what it tested and what it found.
  • Boil-water notices. If your utility has issued one, follow it, and use bottled or boiled water until it is lifted.
  • Lead. Lead often comes from home plumbing or fixtures, so a utility report may not show it. A tap test is more useful for that question.
  • Well water. Test for bacteria and nitrate before you rely on either bottled or filtered water. A pitcher is not a disinfectant.

Who regulates what

In the United States, the EPA regulates public tap water under the Safe Drinking Water Act, and utilities test it regularly and publish the results. The FDA regulates bottled water, and testing and reporting rules differ from tap water. Quality varies by brand. Some bottled water comes from springs or wells, and some is treated municipal water. Check the label for the source.

Cost per gallon

Compare cost per gallon instead of cost per bottle. Here are two examples using hypothetical prices:

  • Bottled water. A 16.9-ounce bottle is about 0.13 gallons. At $1.50 a bottle, that’s roughly $11 per gallon.
  • Filtered water. A pitcher is a one-time cost. A replacement filter that costs $10 and filters 40 gallons works out to 25 cents per gallon. Your numbers will differ.

The filter cost per gallon depends on your water and how long the filter actually lasts. Track gallons for a few weeks to get an honest number.

Plastic and the environment

Most bottled water comes in single-use plastic. A filter pitcher reduces that waste, but it isn’t waste-free. Filter cartridges, plastic pitcher parts and packaging all have to be disposed of or recycled. Check your local recycling rules for the cartridge and pitcher.

Microplastics and other contaminants

Studies have detected microplastics in bottled water, and some have also detected them in tap water. Health effects are still being studied, and the research is not settled. Most pitcher filters are not certified for microplastics, and the sources we reviewed did not confirm that Brita certifies its filters for them. Check the data sheet for the specific filter if microplastics are a concern.

A filter does address some concerns that bottled water doesn’t. The Brita Elite is the filter Brita markets for lead reduction, and all Brita filters are certified for chlorine taste and odor. Bottled water isn’t guaranteed to be lead-free, and its contaminant list depends on the brand and source.

When bottled water makes sense

  • Your utility has issued a boil-water notice, or your tap water has failed testing and you don’t have another treatment in place
  • You’re traveling and don’t know whether the local water is safe
  • You need water in an emergency and can’t boil or disinfect
  • You are preparing infant formula or have a medical need. Follow the guidance from your clinician or your local health department for those uses.

When a filter makes sense

  • Your tap water meets local standards and you want better taste or less chlorine
  • You have a specific concern, such as lead, and you have confirmed that a filter is certified for it
  • You want to reduce plastic waste and save money over time

Brita says its filters are not intended to purify water. Do not use them with water that is microbiologically unsafe or of unknown quality without adequate disinfection. For how to handle that case, see the simplest way to purify water at home.

A quick decision path

  1. Read your utility’s water quality report, and test your tap for lead if you’re concerned about it.
  2. If the water is safe and you want better taste, choose a certified pitcher or faucet filter. See the pitcher comparison or the Brita filter review.
  3. If you need to remove a specific contaminant, choose a filter certified for it. Until you do, use bottled water for drinking and cooking.
  4. If the water is unsafe or unknown, use bottled water or boil the water first, and test it. See the faucet filter guide for tap options.
  5. Compare cost per gallon using your real filter life.

The complete guide to pitcher and gravity filters

ZeroWater vs PUR vs Brita: Which Pitcher Filter Is Best?
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →