Short answer: Neither is clearly better for most households. Both remove most dissolved minerals and many contaminants, and both leave water low in minerals. Distillation handles microbes very reliably, but it is slow and some volatile compounds can pass with the steam. RO is far more practical for everyday drinking because it makes water on demand, and a carbon stage covers many volatile compounds. Choose based on how you will use the water, what your water test shows, and how much time and money you want to spend.
What both methods do
Both methods produce water with very few dissolved solids. Both reduce most metals, such as lead and arsenic, and both reduce most dissolved salts. Neither one is a complete treatment for every contaminant. For a fuller breakdown of how each removes contaminants, see reverse osmosis vs distilled water.
When RO is the better choice
RO suits everyday drinking and cooking for most homes with a reliable water supply:
- It produces water whenever you draw it, at a dedicated faucet or countertop unit.
- Running it costs less than buying distilled water by the jug, though filters and the membrane are ongoing costs.
- It uses household water pressure, so it needs little electricity.
- A carbon stage helps with chlorine, taste, and many volatile compounds.
The trade-offs are wastewater and the need for regular filter changes. Our article on how much water an RO system wastes covers the drain water.
When distilled water is the better choice
Distilled water is the better choice in a few situations:
- Appliances that specify it. CPAP humidifiers and some steam irons are often designed for distilled water. Check the manual for the device.
- Water that may be microbially unsafe. Boiling or distillation is generally more reliable than RO alone when a boil-water notice applies or when the water is known to contain bacteria. Follow your local health guidance.
- No plumbing or pressure. A countertop distiller can be a practical choice for renters or for anyone without a place to install a system.
Taste and minerals
Both methods leave water with little mineral content, and many people find it tastes flat. An RO system can include a remineralization stage. Distilled water can be remineralized too, by adding mineral drops or a remineralization cartridge afterward. For the options, see remineralizing RO water.
If you are concerned about minerals in your diet, food is the main source of calcium and magnesium. Drinking water usually contributes less than food does, so talk with your doctor if you have a specific concern.
How to decide
- Test your water. A test tells you which contaminants need to be removed, and that narrows the choice.
- Decide what the water is for. Daily drinking and cooking points to RO. A specific appliance may require distilled water.
- Check the certification. For RO, look for NSF/ANSI 58. For a distiller, look for the performance data the manufacturer provides.
- Consider the running cost. Compare the filter and membrane costs with the cost of distilled water or of a distiller’s electricity and maintenance.
For a comparison of the whole system, see the reverse osmosis pillar guide. For how the healthiest system depends on your water, see the healthiest water filtration system. If you are preparing infant formula, read our article on RO water and baby formula before you choose.