Reverse osmosis (RO) and distilled water both produce water with very few dissolved minerals. They get there in different ways, and they differ in what they remove, how they taste, and what they cost to run. For most households the choice comes down to how much water you need, what contaminants you are trying to remove, and how much maintenance you want.
How each one is made
Distillation boils water, collects the steam, and condenses it back into liquid. Dissolved salts and minerals stay in the boiling chamber. The result is water with very little mineral content.
Reverse osmosis uses household water pressure to push water through a semi-permeable membrane. The membrane holds back most dissolved salts and many other contaminants, which leave in a separate drain stream. The water that passes through is the treated product. Most home RO systems include prefilters before the membrane and a carbon filter after it.
What each one removes
Distilled water
- Most dissolved minerals and salts.
- Most dissolved heavy metals, such as lead and arsenic, that do not boil off with the steam.
- Most microorganisms, since boiling kills bacteria and the condensed water is collected separately.
- Some volatile organic compounds (VOCs) can travel with the steam. Some distillers add a carbon stage to reduce them.
Reverse osmosis water
- Most dissolved salts, including many metals such as lead and arsenic, and other compounds such as nitrate and fluoride. How well a system does this depends on the membrane and on how well it is maintained.
- Many microorganisms, when the membrane is intact. A home RO system is not a substitute for disinfecting water that is known to be unsafe to drink. If a boil-water notice applies to your area, follow local guidance.
- Chlorine and some VOCs are reduced mainly by the prefilters and the post-carbon filter, not by the membrane alone.
When you compare systems, look for certification to NSF/ANSI standards for the specific contaminants you care about. The test results on the certification list matter more than general claims such as “removes 99% of contaminants.”
Taste
Both methods leave water low in minerals, and many people find that it tastes flat. Distilled water is commonly described this way. RO water often tastes cleaner than tap water because the chlorine and sediment are removed, but it still lacks minerals. Some RO systems include a remineralization stage that adds minerals back. See our guide to remineralizing RO water for the options.
Energy, water waste, and time
A distiller needs electricity to boil water, and most countertop units make water slowly in small batches. A distiller produces very little wastewater, because nearly all of the boiled water is collected as product.
An RO system needs little electricity, because it runs on water pressure. Most standard residential units send more than one gallon of wastewater down the drain for each gallon they produce. The exact ratio depends on the model, the feed pressure, and the water quality. Our article on how much water an RO system wastes covers this in more detail.
Cost and maintenance
Distillers involve an upfront purchase price, ongoing electricity use, and regular cleaning to remove scale from the boiling chamber.
RO systems involve installation, prefilter changes roughly every 6 to 12 months, and replacing the membrane every few years. Check your model’s manual for exact intervals, because they depend on your water quality.
Buying distilled water by the jug can add up over time. Either home system can lower that cost, but each has its own maintenance needs.
Which should you choose?
- For everyday drinking, RO is the more practical choice for most households with a reliable water supply. It produces water on demand and does not need to be refilled and stored.
- For appliances, distilled water is often specified for devices such as CPAP humidifiers, some steam irons, and certain small appliances, because it leaves little scale. RO water is also low in minerals and is often suitable, but check the manual, because some manufacturers name distilled water specifically.
- For water that may be microbially unsafe, boiling or distillation is generally more reliable than RO alone. A membrane can fail or be damaged, and a water test can show what is actually in your supply.
- Test your water first. A test shows which contaminants you need to remove, and that narrows the choice more than the name of the method does.
Common questions
Is distilled water bad for you?
Distilled water is not known to cause harm in normal drinking. The concern with very low-mineral water is that it does not supply minerals such as calcium and magnesium. Most people get the bulk of these minerals from food, and the health significance of the difference is debated. If you have concerns, talk with your doctor.
Can you drink distilled or RO water every day?
Many people do. If you are concerned about mineral intake, or you simply dislike the taste, a remineralization filter or a small amount of mineral drops can help. Our answer to whether RO water is better than distilled water to drink covers the everyday choice in more detail.
Which is better for appliances?
Both are low in minerals, so both reduce scale. Distilled water is the option most manufacturers name, so check the manual for the device you are using. For the broader system picture, see our reverse osmosis pillar guide.